Clone-A-Willy vs Clone-A-Willy Plus: What's the Difference?
By Homemade Dildo | DIY Penis Clone Kit | Published: 2026-08-31
Category: Comparisons
Compare the original Clone-A-Willy kit with the Plus version to see which DIY dildo kit fits your needs. We break down features, molding powder, and silicone quality.
If you're new to DIY sex toys, you might wonder what sets the original Clone-A-Willy apart from the Plus version. Both let you create a lifelike replica of a penis, but they differ in materials, molding process, and final product durability. This guide breaks down the key differences so you can pick the right kit for your needs.
We'll compare the standard Clone-A-Willy kit with the Clone-A-Willy Plus, covering everything from molding powder to silicone firmness. By the end, you'll know exactly which one matches your expectations for detail, flexibility, and long-term use.
What’s in Each Kit?
The original Clone-A-Willy kit includes a mixing container, molding powder, and a two-part silicone mixture. It's designed for a straightforward process: mix the powder with water, insert the penis, wait for the mold to set, then pour in the silicone. The result is a solid, one-piece dildo that captures basic details.
The Clone-A-Willy Plus kit takes things a step further. It uses a different molding powder that sets faster and captures finer details, like veins and skin texture. The silicone in the Plus version is also softer and more flexible, giving the final toy a more realistic feel. Some Plus kits, like the Penis Plus Balls DIY Dildo Kit, even include a separate mold for testicles.
- Original kit: simpler, more affordable, good for beginners.
- Plus kit: faster molding, better detail, softer silicone, optional balls mold.
Molding Powder and Silicone Quality
The molding powder is a critical difference. The standard Clone-A-Willy Molding Powder Refill is reliable but takes longer to set. The Plus version uses an advanced powder that reduces wait time and minimizes air bubbles, which can cause imperfections. If you're aiming for a highly detailed replica, the Plus powder is worth the upgrade.

Silicone quality also differs. The original kit uses a firmer silicone that's durable but less lifelike. The Plus kit uses a softer silicone that feels more like real skin. However, softer silicone may be slightly less durable over time, so consider how often you plan to use your creation. Both are body-safe and easy to clean.
- Plus powder sets faster and reduces bubbles.
- Plus silicone is softer and more realistic; original is firmer and more durable.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you're on a budget or trying DIY for the first time, the original Clone-A-Willy kit is a solid choice. It's straightforward and still produces a functional dildo. You can always upgrade later with a Clone-A-Willy Silicone Refill in your preferred skin tone, like Deep Skin Tone or Icy Pink.
If you want the most realistic result and don't mind paying a bit more, go for the Clone-A-Willy Plus. It's ideal for those who value detail and a softer feel. The Plus kits also offer more variety, such as the Glow in the Dark option, which adds a fun twist. For a truly custom experience, consider the Penis Plus Balls DIY Dildo Kit for a complete replica.
- Original: best for beginners and budget shoppers.
- Plus: best for detail seekers and those wanting a softer, more realistic toy.
Both Clone-A-Willy and Clone-A-Willy Plus deliver quality DIY dildos, but they cater to different priorities. Assess your budget and desired realism to make the right choice. Whichever you pick, you'll enjoy a personalized creation that's uniquely yours.



